- The Former CFTC says SEC and CFTC efforts may still proceed following the CLARITY Act defeat.
- Following the Senate’s 49-50 cloture vote, the focus now shifts to agency rulemaking and future congressional efforts.
According to the former chairman of the CFTC, J. Christopher Giancarlo, the failure of the Senate’s CLARITY Act does not mean that innovation in crypto will be stopped in the United States. In an interview with Eleanor Terrett, Giancarlo mentioned that the regulators will still work on creating frameworks for digital assets using their existing powers. The former chairman specifically named Paul Atkins, the chairman of the SEC, and Michael Selig, the chairman of the CFTC.
🚨NEW: Former @CFTC Chairman @giancarloMKTS tells me the Senate’s failure to pass the Clarity Act is a disappointment but will not stop the “march of innovation” in the U.S.
— Eleanor Terrett (@EleanorTerrett) September 16, 2026
“@SECPaulSAtkins and @ChairmanSelig are determined to do what their jobs require them to do and put in…
Shift in Focus Post-Senate Vote to Regulators
On September 15, the Senate voted 49-50 against cloture, failing to reach the 60-vote threshold. Four Republicans voted alongside Democrats in opposition, while Senator Thom Tillis voted no as a procedural move for reconsideration purposes.
The CLARITY Act aimed at allocating the regulatory responsibilities regarding digital assets between the SEC and CFTC. The act also contained registration requirements for exchanges, brokers, and dealers. It comprised provisions pertaining to ethics limitations and Treasury powers related to the outflows of deposits by stablecoins. The Republicans introduced a new version of the bill prior to voting, stating that it was the final version. They claimed that the bill included 126 modifications suggested by the Democrats.
Industry Demands Regulation from Agencies
In response to the bill failing in the Senate, Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong said, “We can’t wait on Congress anymore.” The chief executive explained that the SEC and CFTC currently have enough authority to formulate regulations for digital assets. In addition, Brad Garlinghouse, CEO of Ripple, called on Atkins and Selig to regulate digital assets amid Congress’s failure.
The CLARITY Act didn't advance in the Senate today, which was a disappointment. While it's possible bi-partisan conversations continue and it lives to fight another day, we can't wait on Congress anymore.
— Brian Armstrong (@brian_armstrong) September 15, 2026
The SEC and CFTC have the tools they need to create clear rules under…
Tim Scott, the chairman of the Senate Banking Committee, separately stated that the SEC and CFTC need to create rules for digital assets until Congress passes a bill. At the same time, Senator Cynthia Lummis condemned Democrats for opposing the bill and its proposed restrictions on cryptocurrency investing by politicians.
SEC and CFTC Proceed with Individual Rules
The SEC and CFTC have already embarked on individual regulatory projects. In August, the SEC proposed Regulation Crypto Assets, which provides an individual regime for specific crypto-based investment contracts. According to Atkins, the SEC will continue its activities regardless of any legislation adopted by Congress.
Separately, Selig ordered the CFTC staff to work on market structure rules for crypto based on current CFTC powers. For months, Giancarlo has been saying that regulators can pursue U.S. crypto policies independently of Congress. The Senate vote brings additional focus to this process as Congress ponders its next step.
Highlighted Crypto News:
Robert Kiyosaki Warns Global Market Crash Has Started Amid Rising Risks
